Interop is a good goal. However, I frankly don't see us ever achieving "total interoperability" by exclusively relying on trademark enforcement as leverage. 

The only path I see currently towards the type of interop that would allow for workload federation across providers is if there was an upstream project, whereby various providers would proactively write and maintain connectors into a central auth system... kinda like an "openstack native rightscale." Those deploying openstack on-prem would then be able to leverage this module to federate on-prem environment with all the providers that have a functional driver. I.e. just like you have multiple storage provider drivers to cinder, we need services providers to write and maintain drivers against something in OpenStack. I've seen discussions and even blueprints on federated keystone in the past, but am not sure how much progress has been made... Thierry maybe you know more?

I.e. there has to be a technology solution to back up administrative action. Not just trademarks and definitions. 

Thoughts? 

-Boris  


On Wed, Feb 5, 2014 at 6:25 AM, Thierry Carrez <thierry@openstack.org> wrote:
Mark Collier wrote:
> To get close to total interop (which I think is the goal, or ideal at least) you have to start where you are (bootstrap).
>
> If we were to, at this moment, define OpenStack as something no current cloud would qualify for, that wouldn't be very practical. I think we can bootstrap while encouraging the trend to move towards the ideal over time.

As far as we clearly establish that "total interoperability" is the end
goal, then I think it's OK to start with some compromises to bootstrap
the effort, then gradually (but constantly) increase constraints.

That said, that only works if there is a bit of consensus in OpenStack
companies that this is the end goal, otherwise you won't be able to
increase the constraints. Does everyone agree on the end goal ?

In all cases, there is a lot of value in having the board clearly
stating it.

--
Thierry Carrez (ttx)

_______________________________________________
Foundation mailing list
Foundation@lists.openstack.org
http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/foundation